AP photo by U.S. Army Signal Corps|
Maj. James A. Ellison, left, returns the salute of Mac Ross of Dayton, Ohio, as he inspects the flying cadets at Tuskegee Institute in 1942.
Historian says records dispute lore of famed Tuskegee Airmen
MONTGOMERY (AP) — It has been part of the lore of America's first black fighter pilots since the end of World War II: The famed Tuskegee Airmen never lost a bomber to enemy aircraft.
Now, more than 60 years later, a leader of the group says he has uncovered records proving the claim is not accurate.
Air Force records show that at least a few bombers escorted by the red-tailed fighters of the Tuskegee Airmen were shot down by enemy planes, William F. Holton, historian of Tuskegee Airmen Inc., said in an interview Monday with The Associated Press. And the group's losses may have been much greater.
Holton said his research shows that while the group's record was stellar, it wasn't perfect, as long believed.
Some surviving members of the group are offended by the findings of Holton and Daniel Haulman of the Air Force Historical Research Agency at Maxwell-Gunter Air Force Base in Montgomery, who came to the same conclusion.
Former Tuskegee Airman Carrol Woods of Montgomery called their claims "outrageous."
"I think they are trying to destroy our record. What's the point now?" Woods, 87, told the Montgomery Advertiser in a Sunday story.
Holton said his sole interest is in making sure the group's history is as accurate as possible.
The president of the Tuskegee Airmen Inc., retired Air Force Lt. Gen. Russell Davis, said he will no longer claim in speeches that the group never lost a bomber under its escort.
"I'm going to drop (it) until we can get this thing clarified," Davis said. "We've got some homework to do, obviously."
The Tuskegee Airmen were the first group of black fighter pilots allowed into the U.S. Army Air Forces. They got their name from the East Alabama town where they trained.
More than 100 kills
With nearly 1,000 pilots and as many as 19,000 support personnel ranging from mechanics to nurses, the group was credited with shooting down more than 100 enemy aircraft and — for years — with never losing an American bomber under escort.
Holton, who has been historian of the association for about a decade, said he began leafing through old mission reports after hearing a veteran complain that the Tuskegee Airmen really did lose some bombers despite decades of claims to the opposite.
Haulman said the group's combat mission reports clearly show that U.S. bombers were lost while being escorted by Tuskegee Airmen in Europe.
One mission report states that, on July 26, 1944: "1 B-24 seen spiraling out of formation in T/A (target area) after attack by E/A (enemy aircraft). No chutes seen to open."
A second report, dated Aug. 31, 1944, praises group commander Gen. Benjamin O. Davis Jr. by saying he "so skillfully disposed his squadrons that in spite of the large number of enemy fighters, the bomber formation suffered only a few losses."
A third report said that on Sept. 12, 1944: "10 Me-109s attacked the rear of the bomber formation from below and left one B-17 burning, with 6 chutes seen to open."
Holton, of Columbia, Md., suspects that claims about the all-black group never losing a plane resulted from something that happened in May 1945 around the end of the war.
In a letter commending Davis, Col. Buck Taylor mentioned that the group had the distinction of never losing a bomber, Holton said. A military public relations representative included the claim in Davis' official biography, he said, and Davis later put it in his autobiography.
Holton, in the AP interview, said it's unclear where Taylor got his information, "but that's sort of where the whole concept emanated from."
Holton said while the reports document a few bomber losses, far more planes could actually have been lost. The only way to determine the group's true record is to scour the post-mission reports of bomber groups that were escorted by the Airmen's P-51 fighters.
Alan Gropman, who teaches at the National Defense University in Washington, said more research is needed.
More research needed
"Even if they lost three or four bombers, it would still be minuscule compared to the losses incurred by white pilots who also escorted bombers," Gropman told the Advertiser.
Copyright 2005 Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Save $84.50 a year off our newsstand price:
Subscribe today for only 38 cents a day!